Skip to main content

Week 3 Part A: Use of Design and Aesthetics on a Website

I chose the Gates N Fences website and MGBD Parts and Services sites to review for my examples of poorly designed sites. I think it's safe to say that neither comes across as being well designed or with the user in mind. On both sites, there is a lot of clutter: too much copy on the Gates N Fences site and too many icons on the MGBD Parts and Services site. 

Gates N Fences has super small text and way too much information on one page (no hierarchy). I don't know what their top services are or how to contact them, and there are about 50 buttons on the left side to access content that probably isn't necessary. 

For MGBD I would say it needs more breathing room overall and some contrast with the images, colors/typography. There are too many differerent-colored links in there. The typography is blurry and hard to read over the images of the cars. The text also seems to be center aligned. There's no hierarchy on this page either. It takes a while to figure out what they do, and I think a banner image with a few major services and contact info would be better.

There is no ease of use on either site. The eye jumps all over the place and lands nowhere. If I was choosing between one of these companies and a company with a more organized website, I would likely choose the latter. Neither website seemed like they were designed with the end user in mind for the above reasons. I think they thought it would be best to put all their information on one page rather than think about what information is most frequently requested or viewed. Overall, I feel both sites could benefit from cutting about 80% of their copy and/or putting it on additional pages that could be accessed via navigation. 

For my well designed sites, I chose the National Park Service and Headhunter Hairstyling. After reviewing the poorly designed sites, these were both a breath of fresh air! Each site has a lot of space and big headers, left alignment, and the names are in the left corner. The navigation is great on both sites, as well. The NPS website has its images in a grid/group on the homepage, which looks nice. And Headhunter Hairstyling has theirs in grids on other pages. I'm also a fan of navigation buttons, which are very action oriented and to the point. I'd say both sites have these. The hierarchy on both sites is great too, with the most essential info at the top. For NPS, that's a search area to find your park, and for Headhunter, it's their services and contact info. I also love that there's very minimal scrolling needed on either site. The additional information is on separate pages.

I personally love the colors of the Headhunter Hairstyling site. It seems perfect for Florida: cool, breezy and relaxing. Their navigation is super easy and streamlined, as well, and the text is left aligned. I actually don't love how the scrolling works on their main page. I do like that they show photos of themselves, since hair care can be a personal service, and you want to know who is going to be cutting your hair/talking to you for an hour!

Both of these sites were definitely designed with the user in mind. For NPS, it's people looking for a park. And for Headhunter, it's people looking for hair services. Because of their professional websites, they look much more appealing to the viewer and as if someone really thought about what the user wants and needs.

I would say going into this I knew websites could be poorly designed or well designed, especially since we do that for our clients. But I had forgotten just how chaotic some sites used to be (and still are). There is one thing I do wonder, however. In certain instances, do these poorly designed sites actually work for people? For example, an older demographic might find them more personally-designed (not flashy and slick) and therefore more reliable... if that makes sense? I am of course speculating and generalizing. But the reason I wonder is because we spend a lot of effort on design and creative for most of our clients--and the majority of the time it is beneficial to their fundraising. But sometimes, for example, at a local animal shelter, people like to think it's actually the Director emailing them and having a stylized format actually hurts. Anyway, food for thought!

I posted on Josephine's blog about the business research: https://josephinecsit155.blogspot.com
(Note: my user name is still SDSD for some reason!)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Week1A: My Spooky Blog Theme

Welcome to my blog! I chose this theme because, well, fall is approaching and my daughter and I love Halloween. Why not get in the "spirit" already? This coral/orange color felt urgent but also fun! I felt this theme had a clean, user-friendly look too-- which is likely what you want when you have people quickly scrolling through content, right? I changed a few of the fonts to make them more legible (no italics, for example). I'm planning to make some more adjustments depending on how many photos I use and whether the format is working in terms of the content I'm putting out.  *Noting here that I wrote these as three separate paragraphs, but the theme joined them all together. I even tried altering the html language... to no avail. Anyway, I need to figure out how to create separate paragraphs on this blog! Let the learning experience begin!

Week 11 Part A: Marketing with Twitter, TikTok, Google for Business, LinkedIn, and more

I decided to look at social influencers and Tik Tok, since I know the least about both of them. I think social influencers (though I really despise the term and tbh kind of the concept!!) could really help me grow my brand. For example, if I had the woman behind FamDiego sharing some of my content, it might be helpful. She mainly stays in actual San Diego, so I don't think it would be a conflict of interest or competition...but who knows! Anyway, worth a shot. I like the idea of having an influencer write a guest post and then share it on their site. So FamDiego could come to an event with me in North County, say, and then write about our experience together. Or just tag me in her post about the event perhaps? And I could do the same. For Tik Tok, I'm not sure how it would be too different from doing a Reel on instagram or Facebook..but maybe I could just post that content on Tik Tok as well. I know a lot of "mommy blogs" (also dislike that term haha) do little reels

Week 12 Part A: Using Business Specific Online Tools

Since my business is community and collaboration-based, I found these sites very fun to research.  I first joined a few groups on LinkedIn: Conscious Parenting, Mindful Parenting, and San Diego 411. I'm interested to see how they play out and what messages come up on each group. I'll check back later this week. I also searched for some groups on MeetUp. I used to go to MeetUps in NYC when I had just moved there and was looking for friends. I did meet some nice people, though I also encountered a lot of odd men who just came to the MeetUps to meet women. So with MeetUp now, I would definitely be very selective in which groups I posted on or events I attended. I joined MomsNightOut so far. I didn't see too many parenting groups in there, so that could certainly be a good opportunity for me to create a couple MeetUp events for North County parents! In the same vein, I could try posting things on Eventbrite, since I often use that to find local events. I don't think Google